Started at 209 on Jan 6, now 187. That's 22 lb in 12 weeks, mostly from tracking around 1800 cal, lifting 3x week, and walking 10k steps.
But the last 21 days the scale has bounced 186.4-188.2 and won't go lower. Waist is down another half inch, so something is changing. Do I wait another two weeks, drop calories a bit, or add cardio? I'm 5'6", 41, not new to this but this is my first real plateau.
Waist down means you're not stalled. Scale lags water.
Agreed on waist. But 21 days flat is still annoying. What's your sleep been like?
Sleep is my tell. Under 6 hrs and my scale jumps 2 lb overnight, every time.
I stalled at 183 for a month, then dropped 4 lb in 5 days after a deload week.
Deload week meaning less training or just less volume? I'm stuck at 176 too.
Cutting training volume but keeping the same daily step count barely moves anything. Two higher-carb days around 2200 though, and then whoosh.
Careful with cutting more. At 1800 with three lifts and 10k steps, you might be retaining water from training rather than holding fat.
I had two separate three-week stalls where my daily weight bounced in a 2 lb range, then 3 lb fell off over four days. What changed? I stopped weighing daily and used a 7-day average, kept protein high, and looked at waist measurements.
If your waist is still shrinking, that's a better signal than the scale right now. What does your 7-day average look like versus 21 days ago?
Weekly average is key. Mine dropped 1.2 lb over a 3-week stall while daily lows stayed flat.
Water retention for three weeks seems like a stretch. My stalls were sodium and weekend eating.
Are you weighing food or eyeballing? That changed everyhting for me.
Weighing helped me, but oils and bites add up. Sleep messed me up more than salt.
Holding steady instead of cutting actually did something — the scale finally moved after 10 days, where another deficit week probably would've just dug me in deeper. Maintenance weeks are the part that scares me tho. Easy to call it a planned break and then look up and it's been 6 weeks.
Half inch off the waist while the scale does nothing is recomp, not a plateau. I'd wait two more weeks.
Sleep is the sneaky one for me. I averaged 6h20m for a month during a stall and was ravenous every afternoon, then got to 7.5 and the scale started moving again within a week. Also compare weekly averages instead of single mornings, my Monday number is always 1-2 lb heavier than Friday.
Three-week stalls are the worst because you start bargaining with yourself at 11pm. I sat at 194 for 26 straight days last spring, same deal, lifts going up, waist down a notch, scale absolutely immovable.
I did the dumb thing first: cut to 1500, added 30 min of incline walking, felt like garbage within ten days, scale didn't budge a single tenth. What actually broke it was boring.
I went back up to maintenance-ish for five days, slept 7.5 hours instead of my usual 6, kept lifting, and stopped weighing myself until Monday.
That Monday I was 194.6, Wednesday 192.8, by Sunday 190.2, so 3.8 lb in six days after almost four weeks of nothing. Not magic, I think it was water and cortisol and glycogen finally letting go, but the lesson stuck: when the tape moves and the scale doesn't, I'm still losing fat, just not losing weight yet.
Side-by-side photos at day 60 vs day 90 look way more different than the 9 lb between them suggests. I'd hold 1800 another two weeks, sleep like it's your job, then trim.
Before you drop anything, audit your tracking for a week, that's what broke my last stall. I was 'at 1700' but never counted the olive oil I poured by eye (a real tablespoon is around 120 cal and my pours were closer to two), the creamer splash, or the bites while cooking.
Measured everything for seven days and it came out closer to 2000 than 1700. Nothing else changed, no extra cardio, and I dropped 1.5 lb the following week.
Cutting 150-200 cal when you don't know your real number just makes you hungry and cranky. One week of honest weighing first.
Your waist dropping half an inch while the scale sits still is the tell — you're probably holding water from the lifting, not losing less fat. I added a fourth lifting day in February and the scale froze at 174 for 19 days while my belt went in a notch, then I peed for two days straight and woke up at 171.6.
Muscle repair pulls water in, and a hard session can add 1-2 lb of it that hangs around 48-72 hours. If you've bumped weight or reps in the last three weeks, that alone can mask a pound of real fat loss.
I'd leave calories alone, log the same way, and compare Wednesday morning weigh-ins instead of daily ones. If you're still 187 but another half inch down in four weeks, that's progress, not a stall.
I'm 5'4" and stalled at 163 for five straight weeks, so I get it. I did the dumb thing first: cut to 1450, added 30 min on the bike, and the scale went UP 1.8 lb in ten days, because I was so wrecked I half-assed my walks and ate a handful of almonds at 10pm without logging them.
What actually broke it was going the other direction — I ate around maintenance (~2000) for 11 days, kept lifting, held protein near 140g, and did zero extra cardio. Day 12 I was 161.4, end of the month 158.
Not saying calories don't matter, but I'd been in a deficit 19 weeks straight and I was freezing cold, waking at 4am, and my lifts were tanking.
The other thing I'd check is what your weekly average actually looks like versus your dailies, because I was 187ish six days and 191 every Sunday and calling it a plateau when it was really a Sunday-through-Friday problem. You're only 12 weeks in — I'd give it two more weeks before changing anything.
187 at 5'6" with a shrinking waist is a good place to be patient, not a crisis.
Login to reply to this thread.
Login / Sign up